Sporked.com 2023 – I’m happy to say that you do not have to make your kitchen into a gigantic, sticky mess this holiday season. Because the best store bought pecan pie is really, very good and no one will notice that you didn’t spend an hour plus chopping nuts.
We lined the Sporked countertops with six different pecan pies in search of the best pecan pie to buy from the grocery store and were impressed by four. Each one brought something unique to the table—like a caramelized layer of nuts or an incredible amount of goo—but they all had a few things in common. Here’s what we look for in the best pecan pie: quality crust, crunchy nuts, sweet, gooey filling. Whether you’re looking for the best pecan pie (classic style), the best frozen pecan pie, or even the best mini pecan pies, this list of the best pecan pies has a pecan pie for you. (And, if you’re wondering, I’m saying pe-cawn, but go ahead and say pee-can. It’s cute. You’re cute. Wanna come over for some pie?)